Are Internships Over-Rated?

Comments

Sorry, Kim, but I couldn't disagree more. There's no substitute for professional experience. As a hiring editor, I wanted to see pro clips rather than college newspaper stuff (though we'd look at both, of course).

Journalism is something you learn, not something you're taught, and you learn it by doing it at the highest possible level. That's what internships are for--to expose you to the real world of the profession and give you what amounts to a professional apprenticeship. You can't get that in a classroom under any circumstances, and while college newspaper experience is invaluable, pro experience trumps all. Frankly you make that case exactly in your penultimate graf.

It's amazing what Google will turn up. While I agree with Mr. Potts here that journalism is learned by experience not taught, I don't necessarily think that professional news clips are the only way to go.

Writing prepares you to write, it's that simple. My job was earned by the work I did at the Gargoyle. Before the Gargoyle, I had never written a news article in my life, but I did write. I wrote, stories, screenplays, term papers. Writing ANYTHING helps you learn what is important to story, people, themes, actions, and that translates into the media business. Those same ideas that would make an English paper are interesting are the same topics that make an article interesting.

I think that those who hire, can see your skill and style through any clip you might have in your file to show. In my opinion, to say that a college newspaper clip is not as important as a pro clip is to put down the education that comes with being part of that paper. College journalists are no less journalists than professionals, they just get credit instead of crappy salaries.

Last point, did you have to use a picture of me with chopsticks sticking out of my head?

Hope all is well Kim.

Post a comment

Already a Vox member? Sign in